Stop Missing What Matters: Why Defining Value Early Changes Everything

Serving on the customer advisory board of Spiky.ai has made me reflect deeply on how often we miss what customers are actually telling us, especially early in the journey. These missed signals can derail onboarding, misalign expectations, and ultimately impact renewals and growth. The more I think about it, the clearer it becomes that capturing customer value from the start isn’t just important, it’s everything.

When customers sign a contract, it’s easy to think the hard part is over. The reality? The real work is just beginning. Many organizations celebrate the “win” but overlook a critical question: Have we truly defined and aligned on what success means for this customer?

Does the implementation/onboarding team know exactly what matters to this customer? Does the Customer Success team understand why this deal was so important to them in the first place? Too often, the answer is “not really.” And that’s a problem.

Because when we don’t capture what customers actually say—their goals, their fears, their definition of success, we leave the rest of the journey up to guesswork. And that guesswork costs us, big time.

The Risk of Skipping Value Alignment

Customers rarely churn due to a single major failure. They churn because of a series of small disconnects—expectations that weren’t clarified, outcomes that weren’t defined, and value that wasn’t demonstrated.

• GuideCX states that more than 50% of churn can be traced back to issues during onboarding or the first 90 days.

• And when customers don’t see the value they expected, they leave—simple as that. In fact, in B2B SaaS, perceived lack of value consistently ranks as the top reason for churn. It has been my top reason in the past.

• Bain & Company found that a 5% increase in customer retention can boost profits by 25% to 95%.

The stakes are clear: if you don’t nail value alignment from the start, you’ll pay for it later—in churn, missed renewals, and lost expansion opportunities.

Why Value Gets Missed

Here’s the hard part: listening well is not easy. Sales conversations are fast, customers share information in bursts, and every call is packed with details. Trying to take comprehensive notes while staying fully present is almost impossible. We’re so focused on capturing the “what” that we often miss the “why” — the subtle cues, the underlying priorities, the exact words that signal how they define success.

And when these moments slip through the cracks, they don’t just disappear—they resurface as onboarding confusion, frustrated customers, and renewal risks.

Most companies aren’t intentionally neglecting value; they’re just not set up to catch it consistently. If you’re thinking, “Of course we listen during sales conversations,” let me challenge that. Listening isn’t just nodding along to what the customer says. It’s capturing what matters and carrying it forward.

What does that look like? It means taking note of the exact words customers use when they describe success. It means picking up on the tone when they talk about what could derail their plans. It means recognizing that when someone says, “time-to-value is critical,” they’re not just making conversation—they’re giving you a roadmap for retention.

When you do this well, everything changes.

• Handoffs stop being awkward. Instead of asking customers the same questions twice, onboarding already knows the priorities.

• Expectations are set and managed. The customer sees their goals reflected in the success plan, and they trust you to deliver.

• Red flags show up early. Hesitation, repeated concerns, silence, these signals tell you it’s time to act, before a small crack becomes a cancellation.

The Power of Defining Value Early

So, what happens when you can truly make value definition a core part of your sales and onboarding process?

• Faster Time to First Value. Customers who know what success looks like hit milestones sooner.

• Proactive Issue Resolution. When you monitor for gaps against defined outcomes, you can act before problems escalate.

• Stronger Renewals and Expansions. Customers who see progress toward their goals are more likely to buy more.

Stats back this up: 86% of customers say they’re more likely to stay loyal when companies provide clear guidance and education during onboarding. And fully onboarded customers are proven to buy 90% more frequently and spend 60% more per transaction.

Think about the last time a renewal went sideways. Was it really about pricing? Or was it about value—or rather, the lack of visible value? In most cases, churn isn’t about competitors swooping in with a better deal. It’s about the fact that the customer didn’t feel like their original goals were met. And that trail usually leads back to the very first conversations.

When we treat those early conversations as disposable, we’re setting ourselves up for friction later. When we treat them as the foundation of everything else, we build a customer journey that flows—from onboarding, to adoption, to renewal, and beyond.

So, What Can you Do About It?

Here is a challenge for you: Pull up the last deal your team closed. Ask yourself three questions:

1. Can you clearly state, in the customer’s own words, what success looks like for them?

2. Does the implementation/onboarding team have that context without asking for it again?

3. Are you tracking progress against those specific outcomes?

If you hesitate on any of these, that’s your opportunity. Because the companies that win in this market aren’t the ones with the slickest pitch, they’re the ones that listen deeply, capture what they hear, and use it to guide every step of the customer’s experience.

Bottom line: Listening during the sales cycle isn’t a soft skill; it’s a growth strategy. It’s how you prevent churn before it starts, how you make renewals a no‑brainer, and how you turn customers into long-term advocates.

So next time you’re in a sales conversation, remember: every word matters. Are you listening?